Deportation Without Representation

One of the most groundbreaking provisions, tucked away onto page 567 of the Senate’s 844-page Comprehensive Immigration Reform bill; for the first time, the United States Government would provide, voluntarily, a free lawyer to an immigrant in deportation proceedings. The bill only gives lawyers to the most sympathetic of cases: the mentally disabled, children and vaguely described “particularly vulnerable”. But the grounds are there for the broader right to counsel for detained immigrants that criminal defendants have received for 50 years and Congress should provide that to immigrants, as well. Immigrants who are detained and awaiting hearings cannot adequately represent themselves while jailed. And while other parts of immigration reform are hugely controversial, providing lawyers to detainees would be a surprisingly easy sell politically, if history is a guide.

In the past two decades, immigration detention enters have exploded. In 1995, the system held 7,500 people on any one day. Now, it detains 34,000 on any one day and 429,000 people throughout the year, in over 250 facilities routinely denounced for substandard conditions such as moldy food, poor medical care, overcrowding, excessive force, shackles and solitary confinement. All this costs taxpayers $2 billion a year. Many detainees are long-term U.S. Permanent Residents with green cards and most have no criminal record. The majority are also nonviolent. They include people like Melida Ruiz, a 52-year-old New Jersey grandmother with 30 years in America, three children, two grandchildren (all U.S. Citizens), and one nine-year-old misdemeanor drug-possession offense.

Immigration detention is a civil rather than criminal proceeding. Yet the Department of Homeland Security routinely treats immigrants as more dangerous than criminals. In New York, while 68 percent of criminal arrestees are released with no bail, 80 percent of immigration arrestees are denied bail entirely.

No detained immigrants are appointed lawyers while jailed. Judge Robert Katzmann of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit calls this the “immigrant representation crisis”. Some detainees hire lawyers or are lucky enough to find free counsel. But 84 percent, in 2010, were not so lucky.

Stuck in detention centers in rural areas like Lumpkin, Georgia or Florence, Arizona, detained immigrants, with a life in America at stake, must argue a deportation hearing on their own – in English, far from family who might find documents or witnesses, against trained government lawyers interpreting complex statutes. Judge Katzmann’s study found that 97 percent of detainees without lawyers lost their cases, while 74 percent of immigrants who were not detained and had counsel succeeded.

Today, 50 years after the Supreme Court granted counsel to criminal defendants in the landmark case Gideon v. Wainwright, most Americans are ready to extend this right to detained immigrants. Support for lawyers to help immigrants make their cases is high and bipartisan. In a recent poll, three-quarters of the respondents, including two-thirds of Republicans, supported lawyers for immigrants facing deportation. A 2009 report recommending appointed counsel for detainees was signed by conservative policymakers, like Asa Hutchinson, Bush administration Homeland Security undersecretary, and David Keene, who later became president of the National Rifle Association.

Without political blowback, Congress has extended the right to appointed counsel to accused violent felons at bail hearings (1984), convicted sex offenders at civil commitment hearings (2006), and suspected al-Qaida supporters in military detention hearings (2012), whether citizens or not. The arguments against doing the same for detained immigrants are weak. Jon Feere, of the Center for Immigration Studies, argues that so-called “illegal aliens” would be “guaranteed greater protections than citizens” because immigration proceedings are civil, not criminal. As law professor and former INS official Jan Ting put it, deportation does not “propose to punish anyone.” Tell that to long-time U.S. residents who are deported to a country they hardly know. What’s more, ordinary civil cases don’t involve being locked up. When they do, for example in juvenile detention and psychiatric commitment hearings, the Supreme Court generally has provided for appointed counsel.

Immigration law has yet to catch up because of the anachronistic 19th-century presumption that noncitizens, even longtime green card holders with jobs and families, are “strangers to the Constitution.” That presumption is beginning to change; last month, a federal court ordered the government to provide lawyers to mentally ill immigrant detainees. And Congress can rectify the situation without additional court rulings. The House and Senate would be following the lead of states that provide counsel in civil proceedings with high stakes, even without a constitutional requirement. For example, 44 states now provide counsel in proceedings to terminate parental rights. Deportation—banishment from work, family, and home—all too often has the same result.

Another argument against appointed counsel for immigrants is the expense. Yet the lawyers most likely pay for themselves by increasing the efficiency of immigration courts, reducing time spent in costly detention, and lowering the cost of caring for children separated from their parents. Detention of one immigrant costs nearly $60,000 per year—about the cost of one lawyer, who could help hundreds escape detention and fight deportation.

If you are in Los Angeles County and need an immigration attorney, contact JCS Immigration and Visa Law Office for help with all immigration services. JCS Immigration and Visa also serves San Fernando Valley, San Bernardino, Riverside, Inland Empire and Orange County, Nationwide and around the world.

Need additional information and advice?

FREE immigration consultation and advice within 24 hours guaranteed.

JCS Immigration & Visa Law Office is located at
2975 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 352
Los Angeles, California 90010

Office hours are Monday to Saturday from 9:00AM to 9:00PM (Appointment Preferred)

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: